A Rising Thunder

By David Webber

Really. If ever you wanted an example of a series which has become bloated and pointless, this would probably be it.
The series started out well enough. Light American mil-SF, vaguely in the style of Hornblower, complete with a boringly perfect heroine, inventor of every worthwhile tactic in her systems war with their nasty oppressive commie-French neighbours. Oh yes, and has a telepathic cat.
Still, fun enough, if not in the least bit demanding, as she captains a light cruiser, a heavy cruiser, a battlecruiser, etc etc. By this point, about 15 books (depending on just how you count it) in she's Admiral-of-the-Fleet in two different navies, high ranking nobility on several planets, and has a whole tribe of telepathic kittehs. And. The. Whole. Thing. Has. Bogged. Down. So. Badly.
A few of books back the sinister manipulators who set up the original war started to emerge from the shadows, as they tried to set up an even bigger war with the huge, but out of shape, corrupt superpower in the area. Last book the Frenchies worked out that they'd been manipulated into war and declared peace, even offering to help deal with the fleet at that point bearing down on plucky little Manticore.
So here we are. Another hefty tome. A huge battle, even huger than the last huge battle. One that you knew was coming, and it did, about 70% of the way through the book. And guess what? The good guys, the ones who've been fighting a war for the last 20 years turn out to be as 'better' than the bloated corrupt types who've not fought anybody in 200 years as you'd expect.
So, several hundred thousand missiles later the dust settles, and one sides ships are unscratched. And the others aren't there any more.
That's the big event. Hundreds of pages in the inevitable has happened.
So what else is in the book? The sinister manipulators twirl their mustachios a lot. The corrupt bureaucrats act complacent and smug a lot. The shifty local governor who's been assembling a fleet so that he can hive off a little empire, just for himself continues to do so, as he has been for about five books now, without committing himself to anything. Everybody carries on doing the things they do. No surprises. Even the tactic employed at the big walk over battle is one that's been the key to the climactic battles in 3 of the 4 last books.
Fortunately, I need not say 'don't bother'. That it's the 15th of a series is enough to deter any sane person.

The High King of Montival

By S.M. Stirling.


Volume four, seven, or perhaps ten of a series, so for God's sake don't start here.
Do you remember The Changes? A series of books by the terribly underrated Peter Dickenson, better known at the time as a BBC children's drama series. The world wakes up with a loathing for any technology beyond the 15th century. There is a degree of chasing about, and in the books at least, Merlin is eventually persuaded to return things to normal. Some people died at the hands of mobs who found them trying to use their cars, but no-one starved. It was a series aimed at kids.
This isn't. At about the turn of the millennium the world changed. Electricity stopped working. Combustion worked differently - fires still keep people warm, but no cars, no steam trains even, no guns. No articulated lorries bringing tonnes of food into the heart of the cities every day. Ships carrying food from the antipodes still float, but drift at the mercy of the waves.
The civil society tries to cope, but fails. Seven billion cannot survive on a world were medieval agriculture is all that's possible. The densely populated parts of the world suffer almost complete collapse, where the people are spread more thinly, and where farmers are not overrun by the starving hordes coming out of the cities, societies can be reconstructed.
In much of America the survivors are ranchers, farm managers and the like. The people who remember real farming, not just how to sit on a combine and mow a flat field larger than some European countries. In Oregon it's the reenactment crowd. Who take it all too seriously. There's a bunch of SCA derived nutters who style themselves knights, and by the time of this book have built castles all over their lands and are honestly quite good at it. They started out as the main villains, but the primary robber baron died a few books back. Their main opposition is a pseudo-celtic clan who practice Wicca and Agincort style massed archery. Oh, and some genuine headcases who claim the Lord of the Rings is a work of history, and develop as ninja dunedain.
After three books of conflict between these groups and others the west settles down to an uneasy peace, and the series leaps forwards fifteen years.
By the time of the next books the protagonists are the children who have only known the changed world, who have been off on what is quite definitely a Quest, involving visions and a magic sword. Or at least a sword of some kind, its only really in this book that the magic becomes unavoidable. So yes, when the tech went away, magic seems to have appeared, much of it not especially nice.
So off they trot, a mixed party of Wiccan hero, knightly heroine, cleric, supporting ninja and rogues, picking up allies and enemies along the was in good D&D fashion. The enemies are largely from a Wyoming new age church who's upper echelons seem to be possessed by demons, plus assorted bandits, pirates and so on.
Come the end of the last book the hero had laid his hands on the Sword, which was proving decidedly magical, on the island of Nantucket. In this one he gets to trek back to the Pacific Northwest, but fortunately manages to do so in just the one book, and only two significant battles along the way, settings up for the big showdown with the evil wizards in the next two, or perhaps three books. Which will probably be fun, the whole thing isn't dragging like some series of this kind of length.
The great question I do keep coming back to though: is Stirling a gamer? There are increasing FRPG staples coming out in these books, but the previous ones, which started off as a time travel story, did seem to be rather optimised for gaming opportunities, and at least one of his stand alone settings resonated strongly with a GURPS alternate world concept I've been playing with for some time. George Martin would probably know, but I forgot to ask the one time I met him at a signing.
Though if he was a gamer, then it's a little surprising not to have any licences out there yet.
Still. Not especially demanding, decent romp. Looking forwards to the next.

Look to Windward

By Iain M. Banks


I was once working in a dreadful factory job, loading pallets with resealed packets of industrial beer, and on breaks reading one of Iain Banks early works. "What's it about?" asked one of my more literate team mates, just at the point the stories had intersected and folded in on themselves. I wasn't quite sure. I mean I'd had a pretty good idea until ten pages earlier, but it had suddenly got complicated and clever. "So not very good then?" asked workmate, forcing me to admit that while I didn't quite know what it was about, it was a very good book. (Walking on Glass, since you asked).
But that was Iain Banks, and one of his early books, this is Iain M. Banks, and I pretty much understood it all along. Which saddens me.
Iain M. writes big spectacle science fiction, generally set in an egalitarian high tech utopia called The Culture. Iain, without the M. used to write strange books which were neither realist nor fantasy, but somewhere in between. Then the M. came along, Iain pushed all his weirdness into his M. identity, and both sides became a bit more predictable.
This one is about a composer, an exile from a caste ridden alien race, now resident on a Culture world, and the emissary from his people who is perhaps sent to bring him home, perhaps sent for more sinister purposes.
There's a degree of structural cleverness, alternate chapters from each perspective, but it's not really breaking new ground. There's a degree of mystery - just what is composer Ziller running away from, just what is the Major's mission, and will he carry it out? Pretty much standard thriller stuff though. The mysteries are petty, the result pretty much inevitable.
Nothing fundamentally wrong you understand, but could try harder.
And to be fair, has. All three of the more recent books I read before getting to this on catch up were a lot more inventive. And one was the welcome return of weirdness to Iain without an M. in Transition. I could really do to read that again in the hope of understanding it properly. Alas, I understood Look To Windward perfectly the first time.

Dragonhaven

By Robin McKinley

Are books about a child and his/her dragon a recognised sub-genre yet? I think the probably are, from the late Anne McCaffery, to training, to sparkly dragonnets who're best friends with princesses. Not to mention at least two iterations in American comics.
This is largely of the same genre, but instead of being fairy tales, the setting is a terribly 'realistic' world full of cyrptozoology. Nessie exists, and following the discovery of a Norwegian community of fjord monsters, scientists are optimistic about a breeding programme. There are griffons and giant Caspian walrus, and of course, given the title, dragons.
Quite a number of draconic creatures in fact, but only the one type of true, huge, flying, fire-breathing kind, and they're on the verge of extinction, surviving only in Kenya, central Australia and the Dakotas.
The human-dragon relationship is a tad fraught. There is, it must be said, surprisingly little evidence that these gigantic, fire breathing predators have ever attacked a human (save for when the Aussies were trying to exterminate them, which is an extenuating circumstance if ever I heard one) and no-one's really sure how many there are, but its obvious that they could eat anything they want, so people are naturally scared. There's a fence, of unknown (to the narrator) mechanism which seems to confine the scaly beasts inside their national park, or perhaps keep unsupervised people from bothering the endangered animals. There are park rangers, largely drawn from a local indian tribe who seem to know more than they let on. There is the harassed park administrator, recently widowed, and his son Jake, who expects to become a ranger when he grows up.
To be a ranger requires that you can cope all by yourself in the wilderness, a coming of age ritual if you like, and while doing so Jake discovers a dead poacher, killed by a dragon he had mortally wounded, and the dragon's dead or dying offspring. Intervening in such things is thoroughly not done (illegal even as it turns out) but Jake saves the one surviving dragonlet, and with the help of his father and the Indian rangers, raises her.
Dragonlets are fairly helpless things, it seems that dragons are quite similar to marsupials - barely formed bloblike infants, pouches and so on, so it's a big job. Eventually though contact with the other dragons is established, proof that they are intelligent and telepathic is gained and everybody lives happily ever after. There's a bit of a crisis with the parents of the poacher, who stir up the public fears of big aggressive child killing reptiles in an attempt to get the park shut down, but Jake being caught on camera being friendly with them defuses that.
The whole thing is Jakes narrative, and because of the secrecy in which he's raising his dragon he doesn't get much exposure to the politics. Or the intriguing Caspian walrus. Alas, he does waffle. There's an awful lot of exposition, which sets up the authorial voice, conflicts with other park staff, pages and pages about cleaning out the cages of the minor dragonoids at the park visitors centre. A good 20% of the book after the big climactic reveal which is more about Jake's marriage than about the changed world.
Good core story, but over long.

The Beekeeper's Apprentice

By Laurie King

There is a deeply annoying phenomenon in modern publishing, the rise of professional fanfic. The renowned writer of detective fiction Baroness James was on the telly the other day talking about her new book, a sequel to Pride and Prejudice. She seemed to think that it was a very brave thing for her publishers to do. I disagree.
It is a murderously safe bet that anything with P.D. James' name on it will sell very comfortably, be it a murder mystery, science fiction or genre busting regency romance. The publishers have an established writer, selling towards her own established fanbase, plus the equally established devotees of Jane Austen. Even if the book is appalling, and being P.D. James, it probably isn't, it will sell comfortably. Which is nice.
James of course is hardly the only one. Eion Cooper is busy writing a Hitchhiker sequel no-one felt the burning need for, Anthony Horowitz proudly announces that he has written the first post-Doyle Holmes novel, blissfully unaware of the dozens, if not hundreds of other Holmes writers out there.
I don't, you understand, have a fundamental objection to writers treading in others' footsteps, it can be a valid way of getting published, finding a voice, attracting a readership. There does seem something basically screwed up though, when a publisher's entire publicity budget is devoted to pumping a very well known writer's dabbling with very well known characters. They've only got so much after all, and there can't be very much left for new writers, with new ideas.
So what, you might well be asking by now, has this to do with the book named above? Well, it's fanfic again, even if the writer is one I'd otherwise never came across, and I wanted to get that rant over.
It is 1915 and Mary Sue Russell is wandering across the Sussex downs when she encounters a middle aged man studying bees. Soon Sherlock Holmes, for it is he, recognises that she has the best mind he's encountered in years, starts teaching her detective skills and they have adventures.
Now the thing you can at least say about this is that it's doing something with the characters and the genre. It's not House Of Silk, just telling a story that Conan-Doyle didn't think of, nor is it Pride and Prejudice and Zombies, taking the piss (not that I've actually read either) nor worse still Thrones and Dominions, picking up again a story that Sayers had sensibly set aside (gave up about the same point as she did).
Once you get over the idea that Watson is an unreliable narrator, that Holmes is in fact much younger than ACD would have had us believe, that characters surely celibate might have wives and families, there are stories that can be told. Some of course have already been told. There are hints in this book (I understand the detail is told in flashback circa book six of the series) of daring boys own stories of Great War Palestine, which makes me wonder if the Young Indiana Jones might be in there as well. But that kind of thing aside, would Holmes have coped with the roaring Twenties, flapper feminism and the like? Not 100% convinced that it's a question the world needed answering, but it is at least a question.
Not a bad book really, read on a recommendation, not feeling an overwhelming urge to read the rest of the series.

Forty Signs of Rain

By Kim Stanley Robinson

This is apparently a science fiction book. It says so on Wikipedia, so it must be true. If true though, it's using a definition that's very broad indeed. It is certainly fiction, it involves much science, and has events in it that have not happened, but might. Does this mean every James Bond knock off or paramilitary gun fantasy is also SF?
As is often the case with a KSR book there are half a handful of viewpoint characters, who interact a bit, but for the most part carry on and do their own thing. Most of them are connected in some way with the National Science Foundation, a perfectly genuine American institution which manages research funding, and may or may not work in the manner described in the book. In the book at least, the NSF seems rather directionless, funding science, but reacting to proposals rather than driving things forward.
The whole book is set against rising ecological... troubles, none of which are more than a step away from today's news, which seeing as how the whole thing is set against the US political establishment involves quite a lot of bashing heads against brick walls.
As well as the NSF types there is a senator's policy gonk, who I assume to look pretty much like Josh Lyman, some bhuddist monks from a made up island nation which is only a fraction above the Indian Ocean on a good day and assorted scientists who might or might not be about to get a grant.
Being a Kim Stanley Robinson book there are a lot internal monologues and more than a few points where people enthusiastically tell each other things they know really. Being concerned by climate change and the American government's inability, or unwillingness, to do anything about it, there's a pretty much continual risk of being terribly preachy, not to mention riddled with trademark KSR infodumps, but KSR is one of the few writers who can pull this kind of thing off. I would probably feel differently if I wasn't pretty sympathetic to the political message, but the book works for me.

The Name of the Wind

By Patrick Rothfuss

Hmm, it's been a while since I last wrote on of these hasn't it? The problem with big bulky Fantasy epics is that they take an age to read, they need some digestion before I'm in a position to say anything worthwhile about them and unless I'm rigorous about getting something up, it's easy to slip out of the habit.
Still. Name of the Wind. Part one of a trilogy, won some awards I'm not in a position to look up right now, subject of a frankly premature re-read series on Tor.com and generally well received. Good book, even if it took me a while to really engage with it.
Our hero is the greatest magician of his age, long since retired, now an innkeeper, hiding from his enemies and his past self. Clearly a well known hero, since all the villagers tell stories about his exploits, without ever realising that he's pulling them a pint. Into this comes the greatest biographer of his age, looking for the tale that will reveal the lost truths of the mighty Kvothe, and over three days the story of his life will be told.
The first day tells of his childhood life as a travelling minstrel, until his family are killed by a demon with a particular downer on folk music, after which he survives as a street urchin, then a university student and budding hero, ultimately slaying a drug addled dragon.
Stockly formulaic as that sounds, there's a bleak depth to the world that raises it above the common herd. It's implied that the rather cozy world of student life with occasional draconic interludes has been destroyed, with waves of demons (apparently indifferent to folk music) overrunning the country. So far it is unclear how, presumably to be revealed in the unpublished third volume.
Must admit though, it fits generic lit-fic plot number one perfectly: old man remembers past loves, victories and betrayals. Hopefully the next will stretch it a bit.